Wednesday, June 25, 2025

Shocking $90-million damages

This $90 million damages including legal costs is said to be the biggest pay out in the history of human rights abuses for more than 1900 detainees in Manus Island detention facilities. This will not stop other detainees suffering from similar horrific claims of psychological trauma, physical illness, self-harm and deaths who are held in Nauru or even whilst in Australia. Human rights abuses are not confined to overseas detention facilities and if valid claims are made, these can be a subject of another or more litigation.

Lead plaintiff Kamasaee said, “I came to Australia seeking peace but was sent to Manus which was hell”. The government through the Minister’s Office, however, denied such claims and said, “Strongly refuted the detainee’s claim and a settlement was not an admission of liability”.

It is uncommon for any settlement to waive privacy or confidentiality, but in this case, the plaintiffs were able to disclose some of the terms or conditions of the agreement and this shows how strong their position against the government and contractors who failed the duty of care in the management of facility involving the detainees or plaintiffs in this case. They suffered horrific unimaginable experiences.

There is no doubt that politicians both from the Labor and Coalition government are responsible for this horrific experiences of asylum seekers culminating in death for three detainees and for other untold miseries. They continued to be detained beyond the period of sentences if criminally convicted for crimes and yet these asylum seekers or refugees never have or had conviction of crime for which they are detained – some are indefinitely and for no reason other than their cases have not been resolved as required. The government seems to use this as an excuse for continued detention even those innocent children. This is appalling attitude or approach to our refugee program or part of it.

As asylum seeker or refugee, one of the basic reasons for applying for a protection visa is that the applicant has well-founded fear of being persecuted by reason of race, nationality, membership or political belief and other convention-related grounds. For this reason, they could not return to their country of origin. Yet instead of being protected from persecution or unlawful acts, they become the soft target of the government or policy that undermines health and security or safety. This is an appalling attitude that we show to the world and it has to stop.

Mr. Dutton has a responsibility to make some changes right after he took over the portfolio from previous government or from Mr. Scott Morrison. He did not do it and should not blame the previous government. If he is not able to improve the image of his department, he should resign or go to another office suitable for him.

Time to say goodbye, Peter.

(For comments or feedback, email cbulos@imemlawyers.com.au)

Charlie Bulos, Solicitor
Charlie Bulos, Solicitor
Charlie Bulos is a Solicitor registered in Victoria. For comments or feedback, email cbulos@imemlawyers.com.

Hot this week

Cosplay Tips from Riolette: How She Creates, Transforms, and Chooses the Right Coloured Contact Lenses

Riolette's cosplay journey began with a single transformative moment...

How to Find the Right Male Performers for Private Events

We're all aware that having the right entertainer can...

A Birthday Delivery Trick That’s Better Than Flowers

Cupcake deliveries create stronger emotional reactions than typical gift...

Make Smartraveller your trusted travel companion

Are you planning a long-awaited trip to visit family...

Filipino-Australian artist duo wins Legacy Award at Asia Pacific Arts Awards

Filipino-Australian artists Isabel and Alfred Aquilizan have received the...

Topics

Cosplay Tips from Riolette: How She Creates, Transforms, and Chooses the Right Coloured Contact Lenses

Riolette's cosplay journey began with a single transformative moment...

How to Find the Right Male Performers for Private Events

We're all aware that having the right entertainer can...

A Birthday Delivery Trick That’s Better Than Flowers

Cupcake deliveries create stronger emotional reactions than typical gift...

Make Smartraveller your trusted travel companion

Are you planning a long-awaited trip to visit family...

Filipino-Australian artist duo wins Legacy Award at Asia Pacific Arts Awards

Filipino-Australian artists Isabel and Alfred Aquilizan have received the...

5 Chic Gifts for the Special Woman in Your Life

Birthdays and Christmas are both times of the year...

Essential Equipment & Supplies for Camping in Australia

Australia’s diverse landscape (ranging from coastal havens and lush...

First Dr Jose Rizal Bust in Victoria Installed at Philippine House in Shepparton

With deep pride, the Filipino Australian & Friends Association...

Related Articles

Popular Categories

spot_img